|
LEADERSHIP
When a leader is good, people experience "we did it
ourselves". They feel proud of their work. They feel good.
As a manager you will often discover that time is short. You will feel
that you would need more time to spend not only with your staff but also with planning and
administration. To increase capacity you have to delegate tasks to your subordinates.
Development LEVEL
Delegation assumes that your staff has a high level of competence, which is not always the
case. Another factor is commitment. Roughly we can divide our staff into 5 different
groups of development.
| LEVEL |
DEVELOPMENT |
| D0 |
Low competence and low commitment |
| D1 |
Low competence with high commitment |
| D2 |
Some competence but low commitment |
| D3 |
High competence but low commitment |
| D4 |
High competence and high commitment |
Each one of these
categories will require a different style of leadership from you. You have to treat people
according to what they know and according to their attitudes to their job.
A person who does not yet know his job or a special task will require
direction. He needs to be told how to do his job and to be closely supervised while doing
it. A qualified staff member will become irritated with too many explanations and with
somebody always checking on him.
A staff member may, however, be very qualified but uninterested in his
job, or uninterested in a special task. Different levels of commitment or motivation will
therefore also require different levels of supervision but now of a different character.
It is important but difficult to identify reasons for low motivation. What ever the reason
might be it can usually, be compensated by a supportive encouraging supervision.
We shall discuss more
about different reasons for low motivation in the chapter "Psychology".
Leadership style
The different combinations of competence and commitment will require different styles of
leadership.
Directing leadership - D1
For level D1, low competence and high commitment, a directing leadership style is
required. The fact that the staff member is highly committed to his task will motivate him
to absorb all the guidance you can give and his competence will develop rapidly.
Coaching leadership - D2
The D2 level is more difficult. Some competence combined with low motivation often creates
a difficult attitude to work, the staff member might think that supervision is not
necessary as he "already knows his job" and will be irritated with somebody
checking on him all the time.
As he already "knows the job" he might however be positive to
discuss targets for his work. As he is not very competent the targets should not be put
too high and the agreed time for inspecting should not be too long. To defend his prestige
as somebody who knows his job, his commitment will rise and he will most probably work
very much harder.
Shorter intervals between inspections will give many opportunities for
evaluation and constructive criticism. If your staff member's commitment to work is
doubtful you must be very careful how you criticise. Give high attention to progress and
give plenty of positive strokes for these. Avoid negative criticism as poor competence
often goes together with bad self confidence which can backfire.
Contracting Leadership - D3
The competent but poorly motivated staff member (D3) has a similar profile as
the previous one (D2). His high competence must however be respected. If he feels that
even his competence is doubted his motivation may fall even further.
"Contracting" is in this case a useful method. With
contracting we mean that we discuss targets and set goals. If your staff member is aware
of his competence he will set his targets high and go for it. Your leadership can
therefore be limited to listening and supporting.
If your contracting is successful your staff member might develop to
level D4: competent and committed. He might however need some motivation to rise his
commitment not to fall down to the D3 level again.
Delegating Leadership - D4
The competent and committed staff members (D4) will require very little from
you as a manager. His work will advance without your interference and he will find his
stimulation and motivation in what he is achieving through his work.
What you will need to discuss with your competent and committed staff
member is only general guide-lines and if you don't give them, he may request them himself
or even help you to elaborate them.
There is a risk however in just leaving the D4 working by himself. He
may have gained his high motivation through your support. Leaving him alone he might lose
it and fall to the D3 level.
Low Competence and Low Commitment - D0
This is the problem case for any manager: Not able and not interested.
The D0 staff member should be moved from his present tasks to something
he is able to do. He then becomes a D2 ready for a coaching leadership style.
|